Consultancy for Study of humanitarian aid as a “pull factor” for displacement in Niger
Niamey
- Organization: DRC - Danish Refugee Council
- Location: Niamey
- Grade: Consultancy - International Consultant - Internationally recruited Contractors Agreement
-
Occupational Groups:
- Humanitarian Aid and Coordination
- Closing Date: Closed
CONTEXT
The Danish Refugee
Council/ Danish Deming Group (DRC/DDG) has been present in Niger since 2014 and
launched an emergency response programme in the Diffa region in March 2016, as
part of the regional response to the Lake Chad crisis. In 2017, a new project
started, funded by USAID’s Office of Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA). The
project timeframe spans from 1 June 2017 to 31 May 2018. The project aims to deliver an
emergency response to meet the most urgent needs of displaced populations that
are not addressed by the existing Rapid Response Mechanism (RRM), particularly populations
displaced for more than three months that are ineligible for assistance under
the RRM.
In the Diffa
region of Niger, concerns are increasing that humanitarian aid may be a pull
factor triggering displacement rather than exclusively responding to
displacement. In the cases where this holds true, displacement is artificial as
populations choose to relocate in order to receive humanitarian aid, rather
than due to a conflict directly putting at risk their lives and livelihoods. For
example, in the last quarter of 2015, the majority of the displaced populations
left their host villages to join/ create spontaneous sites along National Road
1 (RN1) which humanitarian and security forces were using on a daily basis. In
addition, several actors perceive that in some cases, after assistance was
provided to a group of persons in a given location, the number of persons
displaced in the same location rapidly increased. The humanitarian community
also perceives that the figures on the number of displaced or refugee
populations are artificially increased by people registering and receiving
assistance more than once. Cases of entire communities displacing in order to
access assistance have also been noted.
These movements
entail various protection concerns, particularly along unsafe access routes and
at distribution sites. The risk of encouraging displacement and the
overcrowding of distribution sites caused by humanitarian interventions pose a
serious “do no harm” concern as it exposes the most vulnerable people to
potential risks of harassment, physical attacks and GBV, dependence on
humanitarian aid, disruption of regular economic activities, weakening of land
tenure related to continuous movements and conflicts over scarce resources.
Lastly, this could also negatively impact the optimisation of available
resources that humanitarian organisations, including DRC/DDG, require in order
to continue to provide life-saving assistance to conflict-affected populations.
DRC/DDG
acknowledges that this situation is not specific to the Diffa region of Niger and
is also a concern in other conflict-affected countries, although evidence is
mostly anecdotal. The traditional response to these situations consists essentially
of additional, immediate, short term, control measures that do not allow a
durable solution to this situation.
For the purpose of
the study, contextual elements are assumed to be largely exogenous. At the same
time, the research approach shall recognise the causal link between the
security/ conflict situation, the humanitarian space and the geographical
coverage of humanitarian interventions. From this point of view, the underlying
security context can be seen as a cross-cutting element, which the study will
need to unpack as a possible root cause of risky population movements to a
limited number of intervention sites.
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
This study aims at
better understanding the “pull factors” of humanitarian aid. Specifically, the
study will aim to:
- Determine to what extent the availability of humanitarian aid triggered displacement along the RN1 and other locations in the Diffa region, whether as a sole reason or a combination of reasons. In the latter case, the drivers of displacement other than the availability of aid in a specific location will be outlined;
- Determine the extent to which populations choose to durably settle in specific locations and/or choose not to return to their areas of origin due to the availability of humanitarian aid in specific locations;
By collecting data
and analysing the possible causes of this phenomenon, DRC/DDG expects
actionable recommendations in order to mitigate the harmful effects of aid,
ensure a better use of available resources and ultimately contribute to analyse
and address the root causes of displacement, including constraints to
humanitarian access. The main conclusions and recommendations will also be
shared externally and could inform future humanitarian strategies in the region.
Scope:
The scope of the
study will include the effects of the international humanitarian response in
the Diffa region, including but not limited to DRC/DDG funded interventions. In
addition to DRC/DDG activities, the scope of the study will include the
following activities in the Diffa region:
- Activities implemented by other INGOs, organisations of the Red Cross Movement, UN agencies and bilateral donors;
- Advocacy activities conducted by international humanitarian aid organisations towards local populations and/or government bodies.
Target audience:
The findings will be used to refine DRC/DDG
interventions. Findings will also be shared beyond DRC/DDG country and regional
offices with programme managers, country directors and local authorities as
well as the sectorial working groups in Diffa and the clusters in Niamey.
METHODOLOGY
The study will
involve a literature review of secondary sources. This will enable the
collection of preliminary information on the “pull factors” of humanitarian
aid, including definitions and existing relevant conclusions drawn, including from
other countries. Liaison with research institutes and universities, including
abroad, or the West Africa RMMS will be conducted as relevant during this
stage.
Focus group
discussions (FGDs) will be organised within the target communities. In DRC/DDG
areas of intervention, FGDs will be held with DRC/DDG beneficiaries. Beneficiaries
of other organisations (UN agencies, organisations of the Red Cross Movement,
INGOs, LNGOs) operating in the Diffa region will also be consulted. The
consultant/ consultancy firm will reach out to these organisations with support
from DRC/DDG.
Furthermore, qualitative
interviews will be held with primary stakeholders, duty bearers and
humanitarian and development partners (UN agencies, INGOS, LNGOs) operating in
Niger (Diffa and Niamey), in view of sharing experiences and to collect case
studies. Community leaders and local authorities will also be interviewed in
order to collect their perceptions of the situation and their recommendations
to mitigate it. The consultant/ consultancy firm will reach out to these
stakeholders with support from DRC/DDG.
The conclusions
drawn from the FGDs and qualitative interviews will include variables such as
age, gender and status (IDPs, refugees, returnees, host communities) as
relevant.
Actionable recommendations:
Actionable
recommendations will be developed based on the findings of the study, with the
objective to minimise the potential harmful effects related to the provision of
humanitarian assistance to displaced persons and host communities, particularly
in the Diffa region.
Ethical considerations:
In designing and
conducting research activities, DRC/DDG’s standards of ethical conduct will be
upheld. These include “do no harm” assessments and confidentiality of
information provided during interviews and FGDs as well as confidentiality of data, documents and results. Furthermore, the
purpose and scope of the evaluation must be clearly communicated to
beneficiaries and stakeholders before any FGD or interview. Beneficiaries and
stakeholders must therefore give their informed consent before being
interviewed. The consultant/ consultancy firm must also abide by DRC/DDG’s Code
of Conduct that will be signed simultaneously with the contract.
Security:
The consultant/ consultancy firm must abide by
DRC/DDG’s security guidelines and procedures applicable in Niger, particularly in
the Diffa region.
EVALUATION MILESTONES AND CONSULTANCY OUTPUTS
The study will be divided in the following 3 phases:
- Desk study and elaboration of a sound research methodology and tools to be shared and approved by DRC/DDG;
- Field visits including a maximum of 10 working days in Diffa and 5 working days or more in Niamey. This phase will include interviews and consultations with a range of humanitarian and development actors, including working groups and with local authorities and conflict-affected communities in Niger;
- Elaboration of a final report and annexes, including a bilingual presentation of the study to be shared externally.
The consultancy outputs are
as follows:
- A short secondary data review report and a tentative methodology in French at the end of the desk study;
- A draft final report in French to be presented to and reviewed/ validated by DRC/DDG;
- A final report in French;
- Annexes to the final report including a standard presentation of the study in both English and French, a list of all persons interviewed and, if feasible, the database of all interviews conducted.
CONSULTANT OR CONSULTANCY FIRM PROFILE
REQUIRED
- Higher education degree in Development Studies, Humanitarian Action, International Relations, Political Science, Anthropology or other related fields;
- At least 5 years of demonstrated experience in research and project evaluations on humanitarian/ development/ conflict management issues;
- Demonstrated experience in humanitarian operations and knowledge of the humanitarian coordination architecture;
- Experience conducting “do no harm” assessments, an in-depth knowledge of humanitarian principles, of access challenges usually faced by humanitarian operations, and of the main concepts of humanitarian protection;
- Demonstrated track record in elaborating high-quality, informative and analytical reports with concrete recommendations;
- Fluency in French and English is mandatory.
DISIRABLE
- Previous experience working in West Africa/ the Sahel region;
- Previous experience in a conflict or post-conflict setting;
- Flexibility and adaptability to remote and insecure areas.
APPLICATION PROCEDURE
Applicants
are required to submit:
- A cover letter of maximum 5 pages comprising the following:
- Proposed evaluation methodology;
- Tentative work plan;
- Detailed budget, including consultancy fees and health and repatriation insurance. DRC/DDG will cover international and national transport, accommodation and other study-related costs (enumerators, equipment…)
- The consultant/ consultancy firm’s Curriculum Vitae, specifying relevant expertise and experience as detailed in the section above;
- Two excerpts from recent evaluations in French in the humanitarian/ development sectors and/ or protection and/ or conflict analysis.
This vacancy is now closed.
However, we have found similar vacancies for you:
However, we have found similar vacancies for you:
EASO/2021/885 – Call for Expressions of Interest (CEI) - External experts for deployment in EUAA Asylum Support Teams
Consultancy - Remunerated External Expert
EUAA - European Union Agency for Asylum
Closing in 14 days
Multiple locations
EASO/2021/885 – Call for Expressions of Interest (CEI) - External experts for deployment in EUAA Asylum Support Teams
Consultancy - Remunerated External Expert
EUAA - European Union Agency for Asylum
Closing in 14 days
Multiple locations
EASO/2021/885 – Call for Expressions of Interest (CEI) to establish an EUAA list of remunerated external experts for deployment in EUAA Asylum Support Teams
Consultancy - Remunerated External Expert
EUAA - European Union Agency for Asylum
Closing in 14 days
Remote | Multiple locations
EASO/2021/885 – Call for Expressions of Interest (CEI) - External experts for deployment in EUAA Asylum Support Teams
Consultancy - Remunerated External Expert
EUAA - European Union Agency for Asylum
Closing in 14 days
Multiple locations
Call for Expressions of Interest (CEI) - External experts for deployment in EUAA Asylum Support Teams - EASO/2021/885
Consultancy - Remunerated External Expert
EUAA - European Union Agency for Asylum
Closing in 14 days
Multiple locations